Results Summary
Performance
Bundle Size
Build Time
Load Time
Complexity
Performance Metrics
Bundle Analysis
Build Info
About the React Weather Front App
Status
-
Lint
-
Build
-
Test
Links
Usage Instructions
First, follow the repo setup instructions.
Then cd into ./apps/react/
and and use the following commands:
- Dev Command npm run dev
- Test Command npm run test
- Lint Command npm run lint
- Build Command npm run build
- Start npm start
npm run verify
from the root of the project.
App Requirements
The purpose of this project, was to build the same identical app in every frontend framework, in order to benchmark and compare their performance. As such, each app is built to meet identical requirements, which are then verified with the test suite.
Technical Requirements
- Binding user input and validation
- Fetching external data asynchronously
- Basic state management of components
- Handling fallback views (loading, errors)
- Using browser features (location, storage, etc)
- Logic blocks, for iterative content and conditionals
- Lifecycle methods (mounting, updating, unmounting)
Feature Requirements
- π¦οΈ Live weather conditions
- π 7-day weather forecast
- π City search functionality
- π Geolocation support
- πΎ Persistent location storage
- π± Responsive design
- βΏ Accessible interface
- π¨ Multi-theme support
- π§ͺ Fully unit tested
- π Internationalized

React Implementation
Custom Hooks
The useWeatherData
custom hook encapsulates all weather-related state and logic, demonstrating React's hooks pattern for reusable stateful logic.
Error Boundary
The app includes an ErrorBoundary
component using class-based lifecycle methods to catch JavaScript errors anywhere in the component tree.
useCallback & useEffect Optimization
Extensive use of useCallback
for memoizing functions and useEffect
with proper dependency arrays to prevent unnecessary re-renders and infinite loops.
Conditional Rendering Patterns
React's conditional rendering using logical operators (&&
) and ternary expressions for showing loading states, errors, and weather content based on application state.
Functional Components
All components are functional components using hooks, showcasing modern React patterns over legacy class-based components.
About React
Real-world App
Since the weather app is very simple, and doesn't show of the full features of a framework, it may be helpful to see a more practical implementation of a React app. So, checkout:Intro to React
About React
React is the most popular frontend library, created by Facebook in 2013. It popularised the component model and virtual DOM, changing frontend forever. Its ecosystem is massive, with libraries for everything. The downside is that itβs just a view layer, so you end up wiring lots of pieces together. Still, it runs huge apps like Facebook, Instagram and Netflix.
My thoughts on React
React is everywhere, powering millions of websites and used by every major tech company. It's been around for over 12 years, and both React and its tooling are incredibly mature. There's a reason it became the default choice for so many teams - the ecosystem is massive, jobs are plentiful, and you can build basically anything.
But it's not perfect. Our weather app showcases both React's strengths and frustrations. The component model is elegant, useState
and useEffect
work fine for simple state, and the custom useWeatherData
hook abstracts the weather logic nicely. But you're constantly thinking about re-renders, dependency arrays, and manual memoization.
The virtual DOM adds overhead that other frameworks avoid entirely. Need to optimize performance? Time to sprinkle React.memo
, useCallback
, and useMemo
everywhere. Coming from Svelte or Solid, all this manual work feels tedious. But the developer tooling is exceptional and the community support is unmatched.
The JSX syntax is familiar once you get used to the quirks - className
instead of class
, self-closing tags, and JavaScript expressions in curly braces. Controlled components with value
and onChange
work well for forms, though they're more verbose than Vue's v-model
.
React really shines for complex applications where the ecosystem matters. We didn't need Redux, React Query, or code splitting for this simple weather app, but for something like Web Check, these tools become essential. The flexibility to choose your own architecture is both React's blessing and curse.
Choosing a Framework
Stack Match
Not sure if React is right for your project? Use Stack Match to select your preferences and get a tailored recommendation based on the benchmark data.
